SNOHOMISH TIMES BUSINESS NEWS
Published: Sunday, June 12, 2022
Capital gains income tax battle 
|
By Jason Mercier
Jun 12, 2022
The next steps on whether Washington will remain income tax free will be in the courts, as the I-1929 ballot campaign to repeal the capital gains income tax has suspended its activities. Earlier this year an Inslee-appointed judge ruled that the capital gains income tax is unconstitutional. The Attorney General is asking the state Supreme Court to take the case on direct review.
The Everett Herald reported on Friday that the I-1929 ballot campaign was not moving forward:
“Sponsors of Initiative 1929 said Friday they won’t proceed and will instead await the outcome of a lawsuit challenging the legality of the tax.
‘While our polling shows that voters overwhelmingly support repealing the capital gains income tax, our coalition has confidence in the strength of the court case and we believe that the lower court decision will be upheld on appeal,’ said Mark Funk, a spokesman for the political committee behind the measure. ‘Therefore we believe the best coalition strategy in 2022 is to place our confidence in the courts to overturn this illegal tax.’”
Although I-1929 will not be moving forward, the successful ballot title challenge should prevent the Attorney General from playing additional games on any future voter efforts to repeal the capital gains income tax if the courts somehow decide to rule we don’t own our income (as requested by the Washington Education Association in a legal brief).
The threat by income tax supporters to create a “hotline” to make any efforts to gather ballot signatures “as expensive and uncomfortable for them [I-1929 campaign] as possible,” remains troubling. RCW 29A.84.250(4) says:
“Every person is guilty of a gross misdemeanor who . . . Interferes with or attempts to interfere with the right of any voter to sign or not to sign an initiative or referendum petition or with the right to vote for or against an initiative or referendum measure by threats, intimidation, or any other corrupt means or practice…”
I asked the Secretary of State’s Office about the plans by opponents of I-1929 to set up a surveillance system on signature gatherers considering RCW 29A.84.250(4) and received this non-answer:
“This office has no role in the signature gathering process. We certainly encourage voters to fully read any documents before applying their signature.”
Although the I-1929 campaign has stopped its efforts, it is important to remember the shady anti-voter legislative history that it was responding to. I-1929 was filed after lawmakers prevented a public vote on the new capital gains income tax (SB 5096) by attaching a fake emergency clause to stop a referendum on the new tax. In a floor speech, Democratic Sen. Mark Mullet called out his party for the back-door emergency clause used to deny Washingtonians their right of referendum on the capital gains income tax. Sen. Mullet said:
“I find it extremely disappointing that we’ve now moved heaven and earth to make sure the residents of Washington state are not able to challenge this bill thru the referendum process.” (Comments at 52:47 min mark of floor debate)
With lawmakers preventing a referendum on SB 5096 and the I-1929 campaign suspending its activities, the only vote to date by the public on the new capital gains income tax was the non-binding advisory vote in 2021. At the time, 61% of voters recommended the capital gains income tax be repealed.
With the I-1929 campaign suspending its activities, we now wait to see if the state Supreme Court decides to take direct review or allows the Appeals Court to act first on the capital gains income tax lawsuit.
As a reminder, here is what the Inslee-appointed judge ruled back in March concerning the capital gains income tax:
“ESSB 5096 is properly characterized as an income tax pursuant to Culliton, Jensen, Power and other applicable Washington caselaw, rather than as an excise tax as argued by the State . . . ESSB 5096 is declared unconstitutional and invalid and, therefore, is void and inoperable as a matter of law.”
Based on the current briefing schedule in the case, a decision from the state Supreme Court on whether to accept direct review is expected sometime this fall.
Vancouver school superintendent seeks to end learning excellence programVancouver public school superintendent Jeff Snell (annual salary $281,000) says he wants to expel students from the districts popular self-contained Highly Gifted classes and end the program permanently.
Tuesday, September 21, 2021
Bellevue developer fined $280,000Bellevue developer fined $280,000 for multiple dangerous waste violations at downtown site
Friday, July 30, 2021
Montlake BridgeMontlake Bridge closed to vehicles, Aug. 9 to Sept. 3
Thursday, July 29, 2021
Amid police shortageAmid police shortage, Councilmembers Dunn, von Reichbauer secure new funding to hire more deputies
Wednesday, July 14, 2021
PUD Arlington Microgrid Goes LiveThink of the Arlington Microgrid as a clean energy generator with a day job.
Wednesday, July 14, 2021
Workplace safety during summer heat wavesEmergency heat exposure rules define what employers need to do to protect outdoor workers
Monday, July 12, 2021
Puget Sound Energy seeks bids for new energy resourcesAll-source RFP seeks new wind, solar and additional energy storage capacity
Thursday, April 08, 2021
AMAZON New Fulfillment Center in ArlingtonNew Amazon facility will create more than 1,000 full-time jobs in Puget Sound region with $15 per hour starting wage, comprehensive benefits, and longer-term career opportunities for local residents
Wednesday, March 31, 2021
Executive Appoints Michael McCrary as Planning DirectorMr. McCrarys years of experience bring stability and continuity to department
Wednesday, February 24, 2021
PUD Assistance Program for New ConstructionProgram provides incentives and design assistance to help new buildings be more energy efficient
Snohomish Sports Network
Advertisement
Advertisement
Snohomish Times Newspaper™ SnohomishTimes.com Copyright © 2005-2021 All Rights Reserved