SNOHOMISH WASHINGTON NEWSPAPER Friday, September 30, 2022   
Snohomish Times News
Les Schwab Tires
Business News | County News | Entertainment | Local News | Prep Sports News | Traffic Road Conditions | Snohomish Photo Gallery | Snohomish News Archive

SNOHOMISH TIMES NEWS, SPORTS, BUSINESS, REPORT AND OPINION

Governor agrees to keep future government employee compensation talks secret

Unless the legislature decides to step in and require transparency for state government employee compensation talks, they will continue to be conducted in secret

Read

Read more Snohomish Times State articles...

Steady revenue forecast since February primes pump for tax relief

The September revenue forecast continues to show $1.5 billion above expectations for 2021-23 since the February forecast.

Read

Read more Snohomish Times State articles...

Draft Affordable Housing Business Plan

Draft Plan Will be Funded by Approved 0.1 Percent Sales Tax for Affordable Housing and Behavioral Health Facilities

Read

Read more Snohomish Times County articles...

Shooting in the 1600 block of Baker Ave

07/29/2022 Shooting in the 1600 block of Baker Ave leaves one in critical condition.

Read

Read more Snohomish Times Police articles...

Gas prices projected to increase 46 cents per gallon

Washington states new tax on CO2 emissions is projected to add 46 cents to the cost of a gallon of gas as soon as next year, the state Department of Ecology reports.

Read

Read more Snohomish Times State articles...

Shooting leaves one in critical condition in Everett.

EVERETT, WA  Major Crimes detectives are investigating a shooting that left one in critical condition

Read

Read more Snohomish Times Crime articles...

Preview the final stage of the SR 9 and SR 204 improvement

In-person open house set for June 22 in Lake Stevens; online virtual office hours offered too.

Read

Read more Snohomish Times County articles...

Published:2022-09-29 State Print Snohomish Times
Governor agrees to keep future government employee compensation talks secret

By Jason Mercier
Sep 29, 2022

Unless the legislature decides to step in and require transparency for state government employee compensation talks, they will continue to be conducted in secret based on an agreement the Governor’s office recently reached with union officials. Section 39.13 of the tentative 2023-25 contract for state government employees maintains secrecy for future compensation negotiations. Under the heading “Confidentiality/Media Communication” the new contract says (page 176 of pdf):
1. “Bargaining sessions will be closed to the press and the public unless agreed otherwise by the chief spokespersons.

2. No proposals will be placed on the parties' web sites.

3. The parties are not precluded from generally communicating with their respective constituencies about the status of negotiations while they are taking place.

4. There will be no public disclosure or public discussion of the issues being negotiated until resolution or impasse is reached on all issues submitted for negotiations."

In response to public concerns about this type of secrecy the Governor’s office says that “the bargaining process has been consistent across administrations.”

Missing in this statement is the context that the changes made in 2002 by the legislature to allow the Governor to make these decision does not require secrecy. That is a choice evident by agreeing to terms like those in Section 39.13.

Before 2002, collective bargaining for state government employees was limited to non-economic issues such as work conditions, while salary and benefit levels were determined through the normal budget process in the legislature.

Since the collective bargaining law went into full effect in 2004, union executives no longer have their priorities weighed equally with every other special interest during the legislative budget debate. Instead, they now negotiate directly with the Governor in secret, while lawmakers only have the opportunity to say “yes” or “no” to the entire contract agreed to with the Governor. Not only are there serious transparency concerns with this arrangement, but there are also potential constitutional flaws by unduly restricting the legislature’s constitutional authority to write the state budget.

The decision made in 2002 that limited the authority of lawmakers to set priorities within the budget on state employee compensation should be reversed. This is especially important considering the compelling arguments made in the University of Washington Law Review, noting the 2002 law is an unconstitutional infringement on the legislature’s authority to make budget decisions.

Ultimately, state employee union contracts negotiated solely with the Governor should be limited to non-economic issues, like working conditions. Anything requiring an appropriation (especially new spending that may rely on a tax increase) should be part of the normal open and public budget process in the legislature. This safeguard is especially important when public sector unions are also political allies of the sitting Governor.

If the legislature is going to continue to allow the Governor to set the terms for these budget decisions totaling hundreds of millions of dollars, these contract negotiations should be subject to the state’s Open Public Meetings Act (OPMA) or at a minimum, utilize a process like the one used by the City of Costa Mesa in California to keep the public informed.

That process is called COIN (Civic Openness in Negotiations). Under this system, all of the proposals and documents that are to be discussed in secret negotiations are made publicly available before and after meetings between the negotiating parties, with fiscal analysis provided showing the costs.

While not full-fledged open meetings, providing access to all of the documents before meetings would inform the public about the promises and trade-offs being proposed with their tax dollars before an agreement is reached. This would also help make it clear whether one side or the other is being unreasonable, and would quickly reveal whether anyone, whether union executive or state official, is acting in bad faith.

For example, a week before union officials announced a deal had been struck with the Governor’s office they used these terms to describe the status of the secret talks to their members: “Dangerous.” “Hazardous.” “Lowball compensation.” “Disrespectful.” “Unsafe.” “Public services are at risk.”

A few days later the union’s tone changed instead to bragging about the secret talks yielding the "largest compensation package" in history.

State and local government employment contracts should not be negotiated in secret. The public provides money for these agreements. Taxpayers should be allowed to follow the process and hold government officials accountable for the spending decisions that public officials make on their behalf.

As for the taxpayer costs for the 2023-25 secretly negotiated contract, OFM estimates that information will be posted on its website on October 3.


Governor agrees to keep future government employee compensation talks secret Governor agrees to keep future government employee compensation talks secret
2022-09-29
Unless the legislature decides to step in and require transparency for state government employee compensation talks, they will continue to be conducted in secret
Steady revenue forecast since February primes pump for tax relief Steady revenue forecast since February primes pump for tax relief
2022-09-22
The September revenue forecast continues to show $1.5 billion above expectations for 2021-23 since the February forecast.
Draft Affordable Housing Business Plan Draft Affordable Housing Business Plan
2022-08-18
Draft Plan Will be Funded by Approved 0.1 Percent Sales Tax for Affordable Housing and Behavioral Health Facilities
Shooting in the 1600 block of Baker Ave Shooting in the 1600 block of Baker Ave
2022-07-29
07/29/2022 Shooting in the 1600 block of Baker Ave leaves one in critical condition.
Gas prices projected to increase 46 cents per gallon Gas prices projected to increase 46 cents per gallon
2022-07-12
Washington states new tax on CO2 emissions is projected to add 46 cents to the cost of a gallon of gas as soon as next year, the state Department of Ecology reports.
Shooting leaves one in critical condition in Everett. Shooting leaves one in critical condition in Everett.
2022-06-20
EVERETT, WA  Major Crimes detectives are investigating a shooting that left one in critical condition
Preview the final stage of the SR 9 and SR 204 improvement Preview the final stage of the SR 9 and SR 204 improvement
2022-06-13
In-person open house set for June 22 in Lake Stevens; online virtual office hours offered too.
Community Transit board approves plan Community Transit board approves plan
2022-06-13
Community Transit board approves plan to engage communities on service impacts Federally required Title VI plan outlines commitment to service equity
Capital gains income tax battle Capital gains income tax battle
2022-06-12
The next steps on whether Washington will remain income tax free will be in the courts, as the I-1929 ballot campaign to repeal the capital gains income tax has suspended its activities.
Mileage tax is a slush fund for transit Mileage tax is a slush fund for transit
2022-04-16
For Seattle planners, the mileage tax is a slush fund for transit, not a gas tax replacement

McDaniels

Snohomish Sports Network

Advertisement

SNOHOMISH WEATHER


The Epoch Times

Advertisement

mondotimes
The Worldwide Media Guide